Heavy Body Armor not always best
The following story has been circulating in the Internet on quite a number of websites for more than a year. Only one problem: it's not true. Here's the so-called story:
Two deploying soldiers and a concerned mother reported.. that the U.S. Army appears to be singling out soldiers who have purchased Pinnacle's Dragon Skin Body Armor for special treatment. The soldiers, who are currently staging for combat operations from a secret location, reported that their commander told them if they were wearing Pinnacle Dragon Skin and were killed their beneficiaries might not receive the death benefits from their $400,000 SGLI life insurance policies.
The story was first published in January of 2005 by Nathaniel R. Helms, the editor of DefenseWatch magazine. There is a true part to the story - Pinnacle Armor's Dragon Skin body armor is good stuff - it has been tested to DoD standards and exceeded each standard, so no soldier need worry about its efficacy. (1)
However, it is not true that if they were wearing Pinnacle Dragon Skin and were killed their beneficiaries might not receive the death benefits, that's a myth:
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, Myths and Rumors About SGLI/VGLI Insurance
True or False: SGLI won't pay if I die while wearing privately purchased body armor or a privately purchased helmet.
False: SGLI claims are paid regardless of body armor or helmet type. Wearing body armor or a helmet is not a requirement for a SGLI claim to be paid.
My own take on this is that one should make certain that one's body armor is not too heavy:
Case in point:
HUSAYBAH, Iraq - Extra body armor - the lack of which caused a political storm in the United States - has flooded in to Iraq, but many Marines here promptly stuck it in lockers or under bunks. Too heavy and cumbersome, many say.Rest of Story -Marines Decline Extra Armor.Marines already carry loads as heavy as 70 pounds when they patrol the dangerous streets in towns and villages in restive Anbar province. The new armor plates, while only about five pounds per set, are not worth carrying for the additional safety they are said to provide, some say.
ENDNOTES
(1):
Defense Review, 17 Feb 2006, Pinnacle Armor Dragon Skin vs. Interceptor Body Armor Continued…
Gen. Moran now has in his possession ballistic test data/results clearly showing that Pinnacle Armor’s Dragon Skin body armor has been tested to DoD standards and exceeded each standard and far exceeded the standards to which the plate technology is tested at a civilian test lab.



