Wrongly Convicted Gerard Richardson Freed - DNA Evidence Clears Him Of Murder After 20 Years

By Bernie on 12 Nov 2013

Gerard Richardson was released from a New Jersey prison after serving 19 years for a murder new DNA evidence shows he didn’t commit. He’s pictured above (2nd from left) with his sister Yvette, Innocence Project Senior Staff Attorney Vanessa Potkin and his brother Kevin.
Gerard Richardson (wearing sunglasses)
was released after serving 19 years for
a murder he didn’t commit.
Photo Credit: Innocence Blog

In my previous article Has Anyone Ever Been Found Innocent After Being Executed for Murder?, I presented a chart which displayed in graphic form a number of reasons why innocent people are wrongly convicted in capital cases. Junk science was to blame in 9% of the cases.

I believe that percentage also holds true for murder cases in which there is no death penalty phase.

Twenty years ago it was junk science in the form of a bite mark that convicted Gerard Richardson of the brutal murder of 19-year-old Monica Reyes, whose body was found in a ditch in Bernards Township in north-central New Jersey. This bite mark on the victim's back (the only one piece of physical evidence), according to a prosecution expert, was made by Richardson (1).

I know what some of you poor saps believe: that it take a monumental and overwhelming amount of evidence - eyewitnesses, taped confessions, semen, hairs, videos, you know, all that CSI stuff, all adding up to a shitload of evidence beyond a reasonable doubt, blah, blah, blah, to convict someone of a serious crime such as murder. Nope. Nope. Nope. Not at all. If a prosecutor needs a murder conviction to advance his career, then any poor sap will do. Any flimsy evidence will do. Even one solitary piece of evidence will do.

I have read of cases beyond number in which innocent people have been convicted of murder simply on the testimony of a single confused eyewitness (one witness would not be permitted under millennia-old Jewish law), or on the flimsiest of circumstantial evidence, or on a forced confession and no other evidence, or on the single testimony of a jailhouse snitch, or simply because the police had no other suspects that matched the description of the perpetrator, or absent any evidence at all because the prosecutor persuaded the bored-out-of-their-minds jury that no other person could have done the crime.

Last week, Gerard Richardson, now 48, was released from prison when a DNA test [Link to PDF - Motion to Vacate Conviction Based on New DNA Evidence] showed that the bite mark left on the murder victim contained another man's DNA (2).

I call bite mark evidence as junk science because in the past 12 years, more than two dozen convictions and arrests that had been based on bite-mark comparison have been overturned (3).

Now some die-hard death penalty proponents will dismiss this case of wrongful conviction as just one of only a handful. The truth is, more people are being exonerated than put to death. That is why back in 2000, then Illinois Governor George Ryan declared a moratorium on further executions in Illinois:

Justice: Denied The Magazine For The Wrongly Convicted, Illinois Moratorium on Executions Commands World's Attention

Stating that the Illinois death penalty system is "fraught with errors," Governor Ryan acknowledged that the release of 13 death row inmates based on findings of innocence had encouraged him to impose the moratorium. "We have now freed more people than we have put to death under our system -- 13 people have been exonerated and 12 have been put to death. There is a flaw in the system, without question, and it needs to be studied...I will not approve any more executions in this state until I have the opportunity to review the recommendations of the commission that I will establish," Ryan told Chicago reporters. "I will ask this commission to initiate a review of the death penalty in Illinois," he added.

Of course, if we put those convicted of murder instantly to death, say 5 minutes after the verdict, then we wouldn't have all these embarrassing exonerations.

Caption for photo above: Gerard Richardson was released from a New Jersey prison after serving 19 years for a murder new DNA evidence shows he didn’t commit. He’s pictured above (2nd from left) with his sister Yvette, Innocence Project Senior Staff Attorney Vanessa Potkin and his brother Kevin.



CBS New York, 19 Sep 2013, Prosecutor Blocks Release of Man Who Claims Wrongful Conviction

It happened in 1994. A battered body was found in a ditch off Old Stage Coach Road in Bernards. Her name was Monica Reyes. She occasionally sold drugs for Richardson, Aiello reported.

At trial, bite mark expert Ira Titunik testified that a bite mark on the victim’s back was made by Gerard Richardson.

The defense expert disagreed but the jury convicted.

“He stated on the day of his sentencing ‘I will never confess to what I didn’t do,’”


wirednixon.com, 29 Oct 2013, Gerard Richardson Freed: New Jersey Man Released After Bite-Mark Evidence Clears Him Of Murder

NEWARK, N.J. (AP) — A New Jersey man imprisoned for nearly two decades for a murder he said he didn't commit walked out of a federal courthouse Tuesday, a day after a judge threw out his 1995 conviction over bite-mark evidence.

Gerard Richardson, 48, was met by family members and his attorney from the Innocence Project, the organization that got a court-ordered DNA test that showed the bite mark left on the murder victim contained another man's DNA. "I'm starting to believe it now, the cold air's hitting me," Richardson said as he walked down the steps of the Martin Luther King Jr. federal courthouse after posting $5,000 bail.

"I'm just happy to be home," he said. "It's been a long road. This is one step closer to me rebuilding my life.


The Daily Journal, 5 Sep 2013, Wrong man jailed? DNA may toss murder conviction

... bite mark evidence, which was famously used to convict serial killer Ted Bundy, has fallen out of favor. It is not used by the FBI or recognized by the American Dental Association. Since 2000, at least 24 men convicted or arrested based on bite-mark evidence have been exonerated by DNA testing, according to a recent Associated Press analysis.

Separate 2009 studies by the National Academy of Sciences and the University of Buffalo’s Laboratory for Forensic Odontology Research argued that bite-mark identification is inaccurate and prone to bias among experts performing the comparisons.

Forensic dentists examining the same bite marks often arrive at widely different conclusions, as was the case in Richardson’s trial, with the dueling state and defense experts disagreeing on which side of the bite mark was made by the top or bottom row of teeth.

Anyone may republish this article for non-commercial use without asking my permission. I make it easy, see details here.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
If this is your first time here, please read my Comment Policy HERE.

comments powered by Disqus



Email Me

FAQ/About Me


Site Policies


My Articles in Danish

Follow Me:

Special Offer For My Muslim Readers: Please subscribe to Planck's Constant Blog. We guarantee a 100% increase in your intelligence.

subscribe to my Feedvia RSS Feed

subscribe to comment Feedvia my Comments Feed

Visit my Pinterest pagevia my Pinterest Feed


Shameless Advertising

This is what Bernie is Reading Now

For Previous Books Click Here.

Buttons & Widgets

Older Buttons

View My Stats

Blogs That Link to Me:

A collection of things...
Always on Watch
Americans Stand with Israel
Animal Magnetism
Apropos of Nothing
Bare Naked Islam
Basil’s Blog
Blazing Cat Fur
Blogging for a free world
Celestial Offerings
Cmblake6's Weblog
Commonsense & Wonder
Conservative Thoughts
Cosmic Cogitations
Cristy Li
Daily Blasphemies
David Drake
DragonLady’s World
Elder of Ziyon
Empyreum Cœlum
Fausta’s Blog
Fiery Spirited Zionist
Gates of Vienna
Gummihund/ Rubberdog and a proud Orangutan
Hard to Swallow
Hodjanernes Blog
Infidel Bloggers Alliance
Intergalactic Source of Truth
Iron Burka
Israel Matzav
Jewish Preppers
Leather Penguin
Maggie’s Notebook
MFS - The Other News
Monkey in the Middle
My Gripes of Wrath
My Newz 'n Ideas
News on the March
Nicholas Hunter Folkes
No Apology
nothing to laugh at
Oswald Bastable’s Ranting
Outside the Camp
Perigo Islâmico (In Portuguese)
Pirate's Cove
pislamonausea Central
Project 2,996
Prune Juice Media
Ramrock's Blog (In Spanish)
Right Nation
Right Pundits
Right Truth
Rosemary’s Thoughts
Sherryx’s Weblog
Silicon Valley Redneck
Simply Jews
Smooth Stone
So Far, So Good ...So What!
Squid Thoughts
Stop Islamic Conquest
Sunday Morning Coffee
Tales of a Wandering Mind
The Amboy Times
The Astute Bloggers
The Christian Defender
The Infidel Task Force
The Lunatic's Asylum
The Mindset
The Old Curmudgeon
The Political Commentator
The Right Nation
The Sandman
The Sassy Tn’T PoLITicallY InCorrect
The Tao of Torah and Rebbi Nachman.
The Unreligious Right
Theo Spark
Third World County
Thoughts From A Seared Conscience
Thunder Pig
usa stands with israel
Veritas Universalis
Western Civilization and Culture
wine women and transcendence
Working the Web
Xanthippa's Chamberpot
Zilla of the Resistance